News

Joel Kotkin: When the AI revolution is over, trades may be the only jobs left

As artificial intelligence rapidly advances, a prominent analyst suggests that skilled trades might represent the last bastion of human employment, essential for building and maintaining the very infrastructure that powers AI.

Robert MacKenzie
Written By Robert MacKenzie
Catherine Moreau
Reviewed By Catherine Moreau
Joel Kotkin: When the AI revolution is over, trades may be the only jobs left
Joel Kotkin: When the AI revolution is over, trades may be the only jobs left — Text

Key Takeaways

  • Advanced AI could automate many white-collar jobs, including those in programming.
  • The infrastructure required for AI, such as data centres and energy production, will necessitate human labour.
  • Skilled tradespeople will be crucial for constructing, maintaining, and repairing this vital AI ecosystem.
  • The future labour market may see a resurgence in demand for practical, hands-on skills.

The accelerating pace of artificial intelligence development, while promising unprecedented advancements, may also signal a significant shift in the global labour market, potentially leaving a surprising sector as a primary source of human employment: the skilled trades. According to noted futurist and demographer Joel Kotkin, the very revolution driven by AI could, ironically, create an enduring demand for individuals who can physically build and maintain the complex systems that power it.

The Automation of the Digital Realm

Kotkin’s analysis points to a future where the sophisticated algorithms and code that define AI may become increasingly self-sufficient. This raises questions about the long-term viability of jobs currently centred on software development and programming. While these roles are at the forefront of the AI revolution, they are also the most susceptible to being automated by the very machines they create. The ability of AI to generate code, debug systems, and even innovate in software design suggests that the human element in this digital sphere could eventually become redundant.

This doesn’t necessarily mean widespread joblessness, but rather a profound restructuring of what constitutes valuable human labour. As AI becomes more integrated into our lives and industries, the demand for its underlying infrastructure will only grow. This includes the physical construction and ongoing operation of vast data centres, the production and distribution of immense amounts of energy required to power these facilities, and the intricate network of physical components that facilitate data flow.

The Enduring Value of the Hands-On Professional

In this scenario, the skilled trades – electricians, plumbers, mechanics, construction workers, and energy technicians – emerge as indispensable. These are roles that require a tangible connection to the physical world, a level of problem-solving and adaptability that current AI is not poised to replicate. The construction of a data centre, for instance, involves complex engineering, skilled craftsmanship, and on-site problem-solving that cannot be done remotely or by code alone.

Similarly, maintaining the sophisticated cooling systems, power grids, and fibre optic networks that underpin the digital economy will demand human expertise. As Kotkin suggests, “We’ll still need people to build the data centres and produce the energy to run them.” This emphasis on practical, hands-on skills indicates a potential resurgence in the prestige and economic value of trades. Unlike the abstract nature of digital work, the impact of a skilled tradesperson is immediately visible and essential for the functioning of society.

The implication is that as the digital frontier of AI expands, the foundational physical infrastructure it rests upon will require a robust human workforce. This foresight suggests a need for educational and vocational systems to adapt, perhaps by re-emphasizing training in these critical trades to meet the demands of an AI-driven future. It is a compelling vision, one where the most future-proof careers might be the ones that have always kept society running.

Source: Joel Kotkin: When the AI revolution is over, trades may be the only jobs left

About the Author

Robert MacKenzie

Robert MacKenzie

Managing Editor

Robert MacKenzie is the Managing Editor of Fine Times Canada. He spent 12 years at the Ottawa Citizen covering Parliament Hill before moving into editorial leadership.

View all articles by Robert →